Round 1 Winners!
Proof of Usefulness Report

Madeby Collective

Analysis completed on 3/23/2026

+442
Proof of Usefulness Score
Certified Problem Solver

The underlying company, Beauty for All Industries (IPSY, BoxyCharm, Madeby Collective), is a massive, established entity with millions of users and substantial real-world impact. However, the applicant's manual entries are highly vague and low-effort (claiming the audience is 'everyone', technologies used are 'Machinery', and traction is 'most people have used my product'). A penalty is applied via quality factors due to the poorly articulated form responses, but the undeniably large and verifiable scale of BFA grounds the submission in the 'Much larger scale' calibration tier.

Ready to Compete for $150k+ in Prizes?

Move this data into a HackerNoon blog draft to become eligible for your share of $150k+ in cash and software prizes

View All Reports

Score Breakdown

Real World Utility+175
Audience Reach Impact+80
Technical Innovation+30
Evidence Of Traction+100
Market Timing Relevance+75
Functional Completeness+5
Subtotal+465
Usefulness Multiplierx0.95
Final Score+442

Project Details

Description
Beauty for All Industries (BFA) is the home of the largest beauty subscription brands in the world: IPSY and BoxyCharm, as well as brand incubator, Madeby Collective. Through machine learning technology, product innovation, and a community-first mindset, we democratize beauty by delivering not only personalized experiences, but a feeling of authentic self-expression across all our amazing brands. IPSY, was founded in 2011 and is a personalized beauty subscription that inspires self-expression and strives to make beauty more inclusive and welcoming to all. IPSY delivers customized Glam Bags leveraging IPSY Match, a proprietary machine learning technology that analyzes hundreds of attributes to delight each member with beauty products fit for their lifestyle. With an avid beauty community and more than 200 million product reviews, IPSY has created the ultimate beauty discovery platform. BoxyCharm, was founded in 2013 and is a leader in full-sized beauty box subscriptions. BoxyCharm disrupted the industry by being first to market 5 full-size products with a mix of prestige, indie, and emerging beauty brands with an average value of $175* at an incredible price of just $25 per month. BoxyCharm provides unparalleled support to their brand partners while offering their Charmers a world-class subscription experience like no other. Madeby Collective, was founded in 2019 and is a beauty brand incubator that partners with luminaries to develop quality, first-of-a-kind products for diverse communities. It’s home to Addison Rae's Gen Z focused Item Beauty, Becky G's Latinx focused Treslúce Beauty, Complex Culture and the clean, sustainable personal care brand, Refreshments. Check out our Career Site to learn more about life, culture, benefits, and perks across all of our Beauty For All brands! https://www.bfaindustries.com/careers

Algorithm Insights

Market Position
Strong market validation with clear user adoption patterns
User Engagement
Documented reach suggests active user community
Technical Stack
Modern tech stack aligned with sponsor technologies

Recommendations to Increase Usefulness Score

Document User Growth

Provide specific metrics on user acquisition and retention rates

Showcase Revenue Model

Detail sustainable monetization strategy and current revenue streams

Expand Evidence Base

Include testimonials, case studies, and third-party validation

Technical Roadmap

Share development milestones and feature completion timeline